A new Netflix documentary, 'Reality Check: Inside America’s Next Top Model,' critically examines the controversial history of the popular reality TV show that aired from 2003 to 2018. The series features interviews with former contestants, judges, and production staff, shedding light on the show's problematic practices and its impact on participants. It identifies Tyra Banks as the primary villain responsible for many of the show's issues, including harsh treatment of contestants, controversial photo shoots, and cultural insensitivity, such as blackface incidents. Banks acknowledges her role but also defends her intentions of promoting diversity and career opportunities for women in modeling. The documentary highlights disturbing stories, including contestant Shandi Sullivan’s account of being too intoxicated to consent to a sexual encounter filmed by the production team, and her subsequent vilification. Other former contestants, such as Tiffany Richardson, criticize Banks for her harsh treatment and public outbursts, including a notorious incident in 2005 where Banks verbally attacked Richardson, calling her a 'stupid bitch' and a 'slut.' Richardson publicly accused Banks of being a bully and claimed the scene was edited to appear more caring than it was. The series also explores the behind-the-scenes dynamics, revealing how some staff members, like judge Jay Manuel and runway coach J. Alexander, experienced coldness and neglect from Banks, especially after health crises. Barker, a former judge and photographer, defends Banks’ efforts to address difficult topics like race and body image but admits the show often prioritized sensational moments. The documentary prompts reflection on the show’s legacy, its contribution to industry conversations about diversity and body image, and the personal toll on contestants. Banks’ participation in the documentary allows her to frame her perspective, but critics and former contestants remain skeptical about her accountability. The series suggests that the show's problematic history is intertwined with Banks’ ambitions and the entertainment industry’s darker aspects.